By Joe Tatulli
PART
2 -
The Metal Age
In part one of this article we outlined the historical
past. People like William Brouwer, Ron
Massey, and Bob Fireman set the stage for other
designers and engineers to bring even better and more
efficient mechanisms to market. Many of these early
designers were solving problems on the fly and making
what they felt were improvements with little or no background
in the field of furniture design. As the futon frame
evolved two schools of thought developed, both based
on the so called slider mechanism. Some
designers went with mechanics that allowed the frames
to convert from the front, while others used mechanics
that required the operator to be behind the frame or
sometimes at the side of the frame when converting it.
Most of the front operating designs were
wall huggers, to one degree or another.
Both
styles of frames employed the use of a horizontal and
vertical slider. The horizontal slider, which runs along
the inside of each arm stretcher, allows the seat rack
to move forward and back during conversion. The vertical
slider, which runs along the back leg of each arm, allows
the back rest to move from vertical to horizontal during
conversion. They also employed a form of the kicker
or a pivot bar of some kind. Both of these elements,
or fulcrum mechanisms, allowed the seat and backrest
to engage each other and move together in the conversion
process. (Figure 1) Others, like Pete Dodge and Dave
Chadbourn, brought us several designs that employed
springs to help their frames convert. Nikita Griegorev's
EZ used wheels to ease the conversion process. All of
this in the context of breaking new ground. This was
a new category of furniture which had no history to
build upon. Many of these early designers were solving
problems on the fly and making appropriate changes with
little or no background in the furniture design field.
In
1987 Nippon of Denmark introduced the first metal mechanism
for a convertible futon frame. The arm was fashioned
after the very successful Dove arm (Figure 2), but that
is where any similarity ended. The mechanism itself
was very European: elegant, functional,
and based on a simple ratchet system. It consisted of
the ratchet mechanism attached to the base of each arm.
The ratchet mechanism itself consisted of a complex
set of interactive arms. The ratcheting function, built
into the mechanism, allowed the frame to lock in the
sitting or sleeping position and to convert from sitting,
to reclining, to sleeping and back easily, from the
front.
Though
it was revolutionary to the industry at the time, the
mechanism's principle had been around for years. The
application to a product in a growing category like
futon furniture was the key. The metal mechanism attached
to the metal base made the frame almost indestructible.
The price was another issue. Nippon remained in the
market through 1992, but has since decided to focus
on the European market. Today Innovation USA, one of
Europe's premier futon furniture manufacturers, is recommitting
to the US market with their line of Danish metal frames
with their own metal mechanism.
The
China Syndrome
Promotionally-priced imports from Asia currently dominate
most of the metal scene. These frames utilize a very
simple metal-on-metal mechanism (Figure 3) which lacks
the elegance achieved by the Nippon design. These frames
convert easily but their price speaks volumes about
their quality and durability. Strangely enough, consumers
looking for a simple alternative to the cheapest sofa-beds,
have been buying these frames by the container load.
Hot
Metal
Today there are four companies vying for their share
of the metal mechanism, futon frame market. Each company
has developed their own unique solution to the mechanism
issue. Three of these firms are large players in the
bedding business and the fourth is a specialist from
Denmark with an American basecamp.
|

With the most futon experience of the four under
its belt, Innovation USA's mechanism is time tested
and reliable. Since most of its frames are designed
in a very contemporary style the younger consumer
they target is getting a great product with none
of the typical low-end, promotional baggage attached.
|
Innovation USA of Baltimore, MD, the American arm of
Denmark's Innovation Randers, uses a very similar mechanism
to the original Nippon frame. Rich and Cheryl DeBois,
the owners of the distribution rights here in the United
States, have come to the Futon Expo the past few years
and won handily the Best Booth Display with their engineering
and marketing marvels. The Innovation frames are designed
to appeal to Gen Xers and feature a solid metal ratchet
mechanism that works like a charm. The rest of the frame
is well designed and built to exacting specs.
Simmons Futon, via United Sleep Products, has been in
the market for a while. They use an excellent metal
mechanism fitted to a solid hardwood futon frame. Simmons
keeps the category's three components working together
as a single unit marketing the frame, mattress and cover
together. Their one finger mechanism operates as smooth
as silk, and affords their customers a product they
can understand from a name they can trust. With a well
known brand name, the Simmons program works well with
traditional furniture dealers as well as specialists.
Two years ago Hickory Springs entered the category
with their hybrid seat and back mechanism called the
Comfort Lounger®. This mechanism, from a true industrial
bedding supplier, was picked up by several manufacturers
including Broyhill, who continue to produce a futon
frame under the Ridgewood brand name. Crestwood Leisure
Products is also making a great line of beautiful, upholstered
arm, convertible futon frames. Hickory Springs also
introduced its own line of frames featuring the mechanism
at the recent fall High Point market.
The unit includes both the conversion mechanism and
the seat and back decks.
Fashion Bed Group, a bed frame maker owned by bedding
giant Leggett & Platt, has been in the business
for several years. But it has only now begun to make
a move into the category in a leadership role under
the direction of new President Ron Ainsworth. By developing
his products around a Belgian made clik-clak ratchet
mechanism, called the Triple Ease, Ainsworth hopes
to plant the company right in the middle of the futon
frame business with an American made product that will
put his company at the highest possible level among
the few companies producing high end (retail of $599
and up) frames in the industry.
Several
companies have attempted to fit metal mechanisms to
wooden frames with varying results. The typical design
application bolts the mechanism to the horizontal stretcher
on the leg assembly. Today August Lotz, Elite Furniture,
Otis and others (including the four companies mentioned
above) use some type of metal and wood combination on
some of their frames. Each of these companies, though,
uses proprietary engineering designed for their use
only. We attempted to get drawings of these mechanisms
but some of the manufacturers were reluctant to have
them printed here.
In our search for information on manufacturers of
metal mechanisms for futon furniture we discovered only
one. Pat Davis, of RTA Systems, is now the manufacturer
of several mechanisms that have been around for many
years. Made and marketed by a company called Waterloo
Springs, the mechanisms were a standard part for many
sofa-bed makers. RTA Systems has purchased the rights
and dies from the now defunct Waterloo Springs and is
once again making the mechanisms .
The
company manufactures several products which will work
very well on futon furniture designs. The DH-3 (Figure
4a) mounts to an under seat storage box or wood box
frame. The DH-6 (Figure 4b), a second design, operates
identically to the DH-3. The major difference between
the two is where the hinge mounts to the frame.The DH-6
can only be mounted to an arm or some other supporting
structure that is one-half inch from the ends of the
seat/back unit. No box base is required underneath;
therefore, a pair of stretchers that are
attached to each arm provide all the stability required
when in the seat or bed position. It is the obvious
choice for the futon frame manufacturer that wishes
to enter the upscale market without the
hassle of grooved arms or kicker blocks.
Naturally, upholstered arms can be used on this configuration
as well.
By
George They've Got It!
Today the negative drag on the industry produced by
the $39, all metal, black tube frame from Asia seems
to be subsiding. Dealers and vendors alike are finally
seeing the light and hopefully now realize that this
product will never serve their long term goals of growth
and true customer satisfaction. The next generation
of metal frames and mechanisms are of a much higher
quality and target more substantial price points that
keep margins at more traditional levels. The beauty
of the cycle is apparent. As more and more quality dealers
turn to the true value of a better frame and move away
from the quick buck associated with these junk frames,
consumers are getting futons that work well
and in many cases futons that they can live
with for years to come. We have always applauded quality
and value with the understanding that they come at a
price. It seems the current players in the metal game
get it!
This update of the Futon Primer for
1999, a Futon Life Exclusive, is copyright protected
under applicable US copyright laws. It is available
for re-print by permission of the author and Futon Life
only. It is also available, with additional materials,
on the world wide web at http://www.futonlife.com.-Editor
|
Futon Life Tip:
Testing conversion mechanisms, by putting them
through the same kinds of rigors they will experience
in your customer's homes, can be accomplished
by taking a unit home for a week or two with your
family. Making sure those claims are true from
personal experience will easily translate to a
convincing position when you are trying to close
that hard to sell customer.
|
There
are certain aspects of frame construction where we like
to experiment, but the hinge hasn't been one of them.
We currently use an all-steel mechanism that I've seen
used on at least nine of our competitors' products,
so it's a real tried and true product. Now, we even
use the same hinge on our all-wood bodies, and the results
have been just as dependable. It's been an overall solid
performer.
-Marcus Grimm, Marketing Director, Simmons Futon
The
Comfort Lounger metal futon mechanism from Hickory
Springs Manufacturing Company has made a major impact,
not only on the futon industry, but the furniture industry
as well, because it offers the comfort and durability
of upholstered furniture while retaining the style and
simplicity of the basic futon frame. Hickory Springs
has been forming tubular metal since its conception
in 1944 so it was a natural fit for the company to begin
producing a tubular metal futon frame.
Our
design, engineering and operations teams developed many
ideas and searched the world for innovative options.
The end result was the introduction of a patented mechanism;
Fashion Bed Group's Triple Ease. This metal, spring-loaded
system, when applied to a wood deck, has proven to be
the easiest operating futon mechanism in the business.
We call it... 'The Smooth Operator' . -Ron Ainsworth,
President-FBG
|